A New York Times Bestseller
FYI: all the review copies for this title have been sent; please check back on the "comments" link to read what your colleagues have to say.
Deborah Sloan’s delicious blog for librarians, teachers, and other gluttons for good books--all you can read (and write) about forthcoming children’s literature!
"Let's give a warm welcome to: The Picnic Basket. This is just what the busy teacher and librarian ordered! Welcome to the Neighborhood, Deborah!" -- Angela Maiers, educational consultant, 2008 Edublog award
Featured in "Sites that Caught My Eye Today", Cool Cat Teacher blog, 2006 Edublog award
Featured in Learning magazine, January 2009
"Too good and too yummy to keep ALL to myself.” -- Amy Bowllan, "Everyday People" feature, Bowllan's Blog, School Library Journal
“So excited to hear about The Picnic Basket…. Incredible blog…. There seems to be something for everyone….I can’t wait to share these books.” Middle-school-teacher blog
“I will definitely talk about (promote) it during my workshops, as people do like to know about new books and this is a great way to preview. What a great idea! -- Peggy Sharp, children's literature consultant
“What a wonderful idea. You've got lots of good stuff in there." -- Judy Freeman, children’s literature consultant
"Deborah Sloan's The Picnic Basket is on the list. The tagline says it all: "a delicious blog for librarians, teachers, and other gluttons for good books--all you can read (and write) about forthcoming children’s literature!" -- The Reading Tub
16 comments:
My son loves this book! I have to read it in a robot voice though!
Being familiar with the Don Quixote storyline only makes this book more delicious. The illustration's perspectives are precious, Robot Zot's fearlessness has no bounds and his chivalrous love for his "queen" all combine to make a great story, no matter the age of the reader/listener. I did feel a little bad for the dog of the house, but, oh well!
Rating: 5
This book has very colorful and interesting pictures. I can imagine a kid of any age making the connections and loving the book! They need to infer a little in order to understand what is going on, though. It's a very good higher level book.
Rating: 4
Robot Zot is an appealing character and serves as a quality model for the writing trait of voice. Robot Zot's thirst for adventure and his witty sense of humor, make him pull the reader onto his side! This book demonstrates the writing trait of sentence fluency and conventions as well. Who doesn't love David Shannon? His illustrations in this book both supplement and balance the text, by building concrete meaning for the reader, as well as telling a story outside the restraint of the text. The observers and listeners will see things in the pictures- you won't see if you are just focused on the print. See if your students can guess the illustrator by exploring the illustrations (another modeling of voice). I will purchase this book for our school library.
I looked forward to reading this book from the moment I saw the authors' names. The oversized pictures and bright colors make this a great read aloud. The poetic flow of the words are highly entertaining.
As with most Scieszka books, I found this to have, at times, a bit much going on and the plot a bit thin, but it is an enjoyable book that kids will love. Who doesn't love an adorable robot?
I give it a 4.
Sometimes I wonder if I am just curmudgeonly, but I didn't love this book as others did. I did enjoy the illustrations, but I found the text both simplistic and too complex at the same time.
Some of the text was extremely simple but at other times the vocabulary was too difficult for readers who would be interested in the book. I also think the font might be difficult for younger readers to decipher.
I think that this book will resonate with some readers, but I would not take it to every picnic.
3/5
Robot Zot has a familiar feel in the hand. Whether that feels good or bad depends on reader’s preferences more than it does the abilities of the author and illustrator.
Face it, you either like robots or you don’t. Most guys like robots, or at least the idea of robots. Add syncopated text to the mix and be prepared for a fun and lively romp.
There is not much original in the book, but it is fun to read and view again and again. I guess it’s like that episode of Glligan’s Island where Robby the Robot appears on the island and the castaways adapt its skills to their daily routines. We know the story, can predict the outcome, but somehow find it entertaining nearly forty-five years later.
The tangles with household appliances are slapstick. They remind me of some really classic cartoons. This too is a well-explored theme, but Scieszka and Shannon make it work in a fresh way.
Enjoy this book with the boys in your life. If you buy it they will come. This book appeals to the little boy in all of us that still has imagination of things that might just happen one day.
5 of 5
John Parker
Media Coordinator
Andrews High School
Andrews, NC 28901
I was so excited to receive Robot Zot! I immediately read it to my fifth grade class during our long week of state testing. It was a welcome and fun break from the heaviness of testing. They enjoyed the "robot talk" and the unexpected surprises in story and illustration as we turned each page. They highly recommended the book to our first grade buddies.
They gave the book a 5 rating.
Anytime, a new book is published that I think will appeal to boys, I like to celebrate!
As a writing coach, I can see this book being used as a springboard for writing. For example, students in younger grades can be acutely aware of all the details in the illustrations. The wordless pages near the beginning of the book would be a great place to start. Students can create their own Robot Zot stories. On the other hand, Robot Zot also lends itself nicely for a lesson on voice or word choice in older grades. I would definitely model a "robot voice" for these students and challenge them to find their voice to create a new adventure for Robot Zot!
Interesting book!
My rating: 4
I was so excited to receive this book. I mean, who doesn't love David Shannon and Jon Scieszka? I ended up loving Shannon's illustration, as I knew I would. I enjoyed Scieszka's storyline as well, althouh I think the 3-7 age range may be off. I think 4 would be the youngest I would read it to.
4/5
I found myself laughing aloud as I read "Robot Zot!" I anticipate this book to be well received among parents and their children. Even though the last page left me saying, "Hun?" to myself, it is an all-in-all good, entertaining book that should be enjoyed by everyone.
Picnic Rating: 4
Denair Charter Academy
Denair, CA
Budding romance in robot form! I found this book to be very comical in both the illustrations and text. It had a great setting, unique perspective, voice, and was especially appealing to the boys in my class. David Shannon's illustrations were immediately recognized and Jon Scieszka's story turned my kids on to rereading his previous works.
I rate this book a 4 out of 5.
Laura Backman
Hathaway School
http://lemontheduck.com
I suppose I may just be a girl who is bad at speaking in a robot voice but as my young niece would say, "I did not yuv this book". I adored the illustrations. Sadly, I just couldn't get into the story. There is no doubt in my mind however, that it is a book that would be "yuvved" by boys of all ages and probably quite a few girls, just not this one. I will probably purchase it for our media center just for those who "yuv" robots. Take this book on a picnic with a robot and a boy and all will be well. I give this book a 3 out of 5 on The Picnic Basket scale.
"Robot Zot" is boring. First of all, the pictures are amazing and beautiful. The disappointment is I could not understand it and the words didn't help much. I think if you are beginning to learn how to read, it's the perfect book.
I would not recommend "Robot Zot". Preschoolers might like it but the book really needs more details. The different events come sudden and very unexpected.
Our class rates this book 2 out of 5.
Mrs. Brey's Third Grade class
Paradise Valley, AZ
A late post here, but I can't tell you how many times my son has picked up this book and 'read' it. He is only in kindergarten so after a few readings through with me, he looks at the pictures and tells his own story. The illustrations are grand! For our family, I would rate this book a Picnic Basket rating of 4 based on how many times my son goes back to this book.
Your work has always been a great source of inspiration for me. I refer you blog to many of my friends as well.
Thanks for sharing knowledge..
Post a Comment